When you think of disagreement, what comes to mind? Is it two people rationally debating a point where their views differ? Or is it a shouting match, full of personal insults?
For many of us, the last decade or so have felt increasingly polarised. We’ve become so used to seeing people snarling at each other over even the tiniest point of difference that the whole idea of conflict has come to feel toxic.
But as a leader, you can’t give into that aversion. Disagreement is an inherent part of discussion, and an open exchange of ideas is vital if you want to be agile and adaptable in this rapidly changing world. You need to make peace with conflict, and learn how to model healthy disagreement to those around you.
Getting on without giving in
Avoiding candid conversations on tricky topics only ends in stagnation, resentment, or even much bigger blow-ups when tensions simmer over. But being open doesn’t mean being rude or callous. We’ve probably all come across leaders who use “I tell it like it is” as an excuse to be inconsiderate, thoughtless, and unwilling to listen or compromise.
Politics is always an interesting place to look for these dynamics. Before becoming Prime Minister, Andy Burnham talked about the importance of getting on with colleagues of differing views. But at the same time, of course, he had to highlight how different he was to outgoing PM Keir Starmer. That’s a very delicate balance to strike.
I often point to the Political Currency podcast as an example of managing that balancing act. Hosts Ed Balls and George Osborne have been in direct opposition to each other as politicians, but in this context they’re often able to connect across that divide, and to have productive conversations and worthwhile conflict.
Across the pond, who can ignore the surprise success of socialist NYC mayor Zohran Mamdani when speaking with President Trump? It’s fascinating to see how the mayor approaches these interactions – not pandering or ceding ground, but not being bull-headed or combative either. He focuses on what the two have in common (getting on), while standing firm on important points (not giving in), an approach that seems to have been highly effective.
In the workplace, we’re so often trying to get to the same place, and just disagreeing on how. That’s why it’s so important to learn how to unhitch disagreement from personal discord.
The conflict paradox
When an avoidance of conflict becomes institutionalised, that conflict doesn’t go away. It goes underground. In other words: suppressing conflict only breeds more, and deeper, division.
A perfect example is the secret online Feminist Fight Club group that Sarah Wynn-Williams included in her book Careless People. It became a space for female staffers at Facebook to vent their frustrations with the company culture – frustrations which, crucially, they felt completely unable to take to their managers.
When you don’t map out healthy conflict as a leader, or allow disagreements, that doesn’t mean the conflict evaporates. You just don’t know about it. People will find ways to connect with and support each other in a toxic workplace – or they’ll leave, taking their skills and knowledge with them.
Disagreement is just part of dialogue
For some people, words like conflict and disagreement carry a lot of baggage. They imply discord, disharmony, anger and personal attacks. If you feel that way about them, I’d encourage you to try reframing them as discussion or dialogue – things we know are essential to progress in a business setting.
In reality, people talking about a topic where their views differ is nothing scary. In fact, it’s completely normal! Encouraging everyone to keep their thoughts to themselves only limits the healthy exchange of ideas, leading to a quiet polarisation and entrenchment of views that can become very dangerous.
At a time when that polarisation is evident in so many areas of life, I was pleased to see that the theme at Davos this January was ‘A Spirit of Dialogue’. As we move towards the end of the year, I’d like to invite you to reflect on that theme in your own practices as a leader. How do you carry a spirit of dialogue into your work? And what practical steps can you take to spread that openness and cooperation throughout your organisation?